Review of ABC's "For Life" TV Series - The New York TImes

Traditionally, each month’s “Reference Materials” section includes, inter alia, book reviews from –

The New York Times
The Wall Street Journal
The Washington Post

None of them reviewed “Marked for Life” – presumably because this is a “cart before the horse” situation with the story of “Marked for Life” being portrayed in a TV series entitled “For Life” and airing for two seasons on ABC 2020-2021, while “Marked for Life” was not published until 11/8/2022 – with the NYT and WaPo already having reviewed “For Life.”

The WSJ appears to have shirked its duty by not even reviewing “For Life.” Accordingly, its place is taken by The New York Post which is the nation’s oldest daily newspaper (established 1801 by Alexander Hamilton) and which has been conservative since being acquired by Rupert Murdoch in 1976 (long before Murdoch acquired the WSJ in 2007).

Accordingly, this section includes, inter alia, the reviews of ABC’s “For Life” from –

The New York Times
The New York Post
The Washington Post
The American Bar Association Journal (which is referenced in Q&A-18 & Q&A-19 of the First Short Quiz)
Post Reply
Posts: 2069
Joined: Fri Jun 29, 2007 8:43 pm

Review of ABC's "For Life" TV Series - The New York TImes

Post by johnkarls »

. ... -life.html

Review: A Jailhouse Lawyer (With a Law Degree) in ABC’s ‘For Life’
Inspired by a real-life story, the new series is a more nuanced than usual take on the legal-prison-mystery-family drama.

Review By Mike Hale - has been a television critic for The Times since 2009.

Feb. 10, 2020

“For Life,” the new ABC drama about a Bronx inmate on a life sentence who becomes a lawyer, belongs in the small but increasingly relevant genre of the unjust-incarceration story, joining works like the currently screening film “Just Mercy” and Ava Duvernay’s Netflix documentary, “13th.”

As a drama series focused on a particular social-justice issue, with specific reference to race, it’s in tune with the times — such shows are common on cable and streaming — but still a rarity on broadcast-network television. That might be why it’s arriving in February (13 episodes beginning Tuesday), away from ABC’s more prominent fall premieres, the popcorn dramas “Emergence” and “Stumptown.” (It recalls Fox’s spring showing of the police-shooting drama “Shots Fired” in 2017.)

So the debut of “For Life” serves as a small marker in an evolving national conversation. But it’s also an indication — and this is more interesting, from a critic’s point of view — that ABC is maintaining its current roll. The sci-fi adventure “Emergence” and the private-eye drama “Stumptown” emerged, along with CBS’s “Evil,” as the most entertaining and emotionally engaging shows the Big 5 networks came up with last fall. And “For Life” also looks promising, though critics were given only three episodes to go on.

Better-than-the-network-average has been the byword of the show’s creator, Hank Steinberg, whose previous series were “The Nine,” “Without a Trace” and “The Last Ship.” They played unusual variations on crime and combat formulas, and their inventiveness was always notable if not always successful. (One of the show’s executive producers is Curtis Jackson, better known as 50 Cent, who’s also a producer of the Starz series “Power.”)

In “For Life,” which is loosely inspired by the story of a former New Jersey inmate, Isaac Wright Jr., Steinberg doesn’t shirk the familiar images and situations of the jailhouse story. We get the rushed phone calls, the stare-downs in the yard, the tense and cramped conversations in the visiting room.

They’re handled with restraint and finesse, though. And the big moments of inspiration and melodrama — the courtroom victories and family rapprochements that are unavoidable in this story, from this source — are also more subtle than the network norm. (It’s noticeable, too, that Steinberg chose to start the action after the central character, Aaron Wallace, had already spent years getting his law degree and winning the right to argue for other prisoners in court, forgoing all that ready-made poignancy.)

Some of that nuance is down to Steinberg, who wrote the first three episodes, and to sure-handed direction from George Tillman Jr. and Russell Fine. But a lot of it has to do with casting, beginning with the steady, measured performance of Nicholas Pinnock as Wallace, who’s nine years into a life sentence after being framed for a drug crime.

As good or better in a smaller role is another excellent British performer, Indira Varma, who plays Safiya Masry, the enlightened warden of the prison where Wallace is housed. Masry is Wallace’s ally but his double-pronged strategy, in which he uses the cases of other prisoners as part of a long-term campaign to free himself, often threatens her own position. Without any histrionics or posturing, Varma nails the character’s blend of idealism and realpolitik, compassion and trepidation.

One interesting thing about “For Life,” at this early stage, is how it takes a story grounded in race — Wallace, an African-American, is railroaded by a white district attorney, Glen Maskins (Boris McGiver, whose ability to combine menace and condescension is perfectly used) — and then crosses it up. Wallace’s need to cooperate, and coexist, with representatives of the prison and legal systems puts him in precarious situations, and reveals how loyalties can run deeper along institutional lines than racial ones.

The most interesting thing, though, in both dramatic and thematic terms, is Wallace’s willingness to bend and break the rules to advance his agenda — from his choices of which inmates’ causes to adopt, to lying, to outright fabrication of evidence. Steinberg is similarly calculating: He initially shocks us with how far Wallace, the show’s paragon, is willing to go, before sketching in how a stacked system fuels Wallace’s feelings of desperation and justification.

The viewer is on Wallace’s side, of course, but so far the show doesn’t try to tell us how we should feel about his tactics, and that’s a winning strategy.

Post Reply

Return to “Reference Materials – Marked for Life: One Man's Fight for Justice from the Inside – April 19”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest